Michelle
Nicole is Paige’s best friend; in fact, she is Paige’s “sister” in the same way the Andersons are mine, and she is her maid of honor. She has been a major part of Paige and my love story. First and foremost, she helped me ask Paige to be my girlfriend (The Scroll). While I mentioned her twice last season, her last full appearance was in the first part of the Season 7 finale, October-December. I wanted to take this installment to catch up with Nicole and show how she has been helping us in our engagement.
On Sunday, January 26, 2025, Paige and I took my cousins, Lexi and Caitlynn, to the mall to help Caitlynn get something for my grandpa‘s funeral the next day. Toward the end of our trip, we wanted Starbucks, and when my order came up, the barista called me “Michelle.” Then on that Friday, January 31, Paige and I went out to Pins to celebrate Clo’s birthday (They Grow Up So Fast). When we left Pins, Clo wanted Cane‘s, so we went there. I ordered, and as Paige and I were telling Clo the Starbucks story, wouldn’t you know it, one of the Cane’s employees yelled, “Order for Michelle.”
Now, earlier that month, Nicole had started dating a guy, who we’ll call Carson. The day after we hung out with Clo, Paige, and I went out to dinner with Nicole, Carson, and one of Nicole's friends at a restaurant that, ironically, was in the same mall we had been to on Sunday.
I was out here making a great first impression. The whole table was laughing, and they were all loving me, and it was awesome. Having known Carson now for over a year, I've come to the conclusion that he is a very funny person, but I don’t think he was ready for me to be as funny as I was that night. At some point, Paige told the whole Michelle story.
Now I wish I could remember the setup for this. I don’t remember exactly what was said, but after Paige told that story, Carson kept calling me “Michelle.” At some point, I said something, and Carson jokingly asked, “Michelle, are you pregnant?”
What I said next came out of my mouth before my brain had processed what I was thinking. “Yes,” I replied, “and Nicole’s the father!”
That comment solidified Carson and my friendship. And I would like to add this little bit has not stopped. Every couple of months, some random person in the food service industry, not to mention Carson, calls me Michelle, and it’s hilarious.
Nicole continues to be a major part of our story. On May 9th, 2025, Nicole kidnapped Paige, got her into the dress that she wanted to be in, got her nails painted, and drove Paige to Good Night John Boy, the bar that Paige and I had a first date at. Once Paige walked in, she and I started a scavenger hunt that ended with me proposing to her (The Scroll Of Proposal). About a month after Paige and I got engaged, Carson proposed to Nicole. Over last summer, Nicole figured out most of her and Carson’s wedding stuff, while Paige and I were getting very overwhelmed. While Paige and I were on my family vacation in July, I talked on the phone with Nicole for like an hour, and she helped me with some of the anxieties. And that is on top of the usual maid-of-honor duties. I know they already went wedding dress shopping; she has been there for some meetings we had with our parents, and she has continued to give us advice on managing wedding-planning anxiety.
There are a lot of people who are supporting Paige and I, and we appreciate all of them. Over the last few months, I’ve learned that having another 2026 bride on the team has been a huge asset for us!
Have a Greattastic day and be safe,
J. Mitchie Ulibarri, SBT